Does Clearing A False TOEIC Allegation Entitle You To Indefinite Leave To Remain?

TOEIC allegation
Last reviewed on 14 November 2026

TL;DR: Overturning an incorrect TOEIC allegation does not mean you will automatically get indefinite leave to remain (ILR). In a recent judgment, the Court of Appeal stated that the Home Office must consider your individual circumstances, including the injustice you experienced and any subsequent events that followed on from the inaccurate decision.

Introduction

Beginning in 2014, the UK Home Office falsely accused over 35,000 international students of cheating on TOEIC (Test of English for International Communication) English tests. A BBC Panorama investigation revealed that two test providers were running fraudulent exams, allowing people to claim they had passed when applying for leave to enter or remain in the UK. This led to the Home Office making false cheating allegations that are still impacting people to this day. The recent case of Secretary of State for the Home Department v Hossain [2026] EWCA Civ 1310 provides a stark reminder that simply because a person may have been a victim of a previous injustice does not mean they will automatically be granted settlement in the UK.

What happened in Secretary of State for the Home Department v Hossain?

Mr Hossain arrived in Britain as a student in 2009. In 2014 he was refused further leave to remain in the UK on the grounds of deception concerning his TOEIC.

The First-tier Tribunal ruled Mr Hossain had not cheated on his English language test, and the Home Office granted him permission to stay in the country for 30 months. This was in November 2023. However, the Home Office refused his ILR application, and he brought a judicial review to challenge the lawfulness of that refusal.

Mr Hossain’s ILR application relied on ten years’ continuous lawful residence. The issue for the court was whether the period after the refused further leave to remain in the UK, based on the false cheating allegations, had to be treated as lawful residence for settlement purposes.

The High Court ruled in the applicants’ favour, and the Home Office appealed.

Why was settlement refused despite the injustice?

The Court of Appeal held that the Home Secretary could consider events that happened after the wrongful decision regarding the English language test when deciding whether to grant ILR for further permission to remain.

Lord Justice Baker described the outcome as turning on a “fact-specific exercise of discretion in each case”. The court ruled that Mr Hossain’s failure to comply with immigration bail reporting requirements and his delay in legalising his right to remain in the UK could count against him. The court found that the Home Office had properly considered the injustice Mr Hossain had suffered, but this did not mean the Home Office had to grant him ILR regardless of any other circumstances.

What this decision means for you

The Court of Appeal made clear that every case of this type would be considered on its own facts. Therefore, if you were falsely accused of cheating on your TOEIC, subsequently cleared, and now wish to apply for indefinite leave to remain, make sure you:

  • Keep all the documents relating to the accusation of cheating and the tribunal’s decision clearing you. Also, retain all your applications for leave to remain and Home Office responses, with evidence explaining periods when your immigration status could not be resolved.
  • Check exactly what the tribunal decided about deception. The Home Office’s ETS guidance recognises that an appeal can succeed on human rights grounds without a finding that the person did not cheat.
  • Make sure your Immigration Solicitor explains your situation clearly to you. Keep evidence of the consequences of the allegation, such as interrupted studies or lost employment, to illustrate the harm the false allegation caused you and your family.

FAQs

Can I still obtain settlement?

Yes, if you satisfy the requirements, you may be granted ILR.

Did Mr Hossain lose his existing permission to stay in the UK?

No, the Court of Appeal expressly confirmed that its decision did not affect his existing extended permission or pending application.

How can I increase my chances of having ILR granted?

Talk to our Immigration Law Solicitors, who can assess your immigration history before you make a settlement application. Ask your adviser to explain which residence periods can count and what further evidence is needed. If you have received a refusal, contact us immediately, as we must bring a judicial review application within three months.

Getting legal advice

To talk to us about what to do following an ILR refusal and/or false allegations made by the Home Office, please contact our team on +44 (0) 20 7269 9590 or email info@gulbenkian.co.uk to discuss your circumstances.

Please note that this article is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Gulbenkian Andonian Solicitors

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.